Michigan Juvenile Defense
Michigan treats most criminal matters involving people under 18 as juvenile cases handled in the family division of the circuit court under MCL 712A.1 et seq. Juvenile court is a separate system from adult criminal court — different procedures, different outcomes, and different terminology. But certain serious cases can be transferred to, waived into, or designated for adult treatment, and the consequences of a juvenile adjudication can follow a person well into adulthood if not properly addressed.
This article walks through how Michigan juvenile cases proceed, when a case moves into the adult system, the dispositions available to the family court, and the defenses that apply. The Law Offices of Joseph A. Simon, PLLC has defended juvenile cases in Washtenaw, Wayne, Jackson, Livingston, and Lenawee County courts for over 40 years.
Jurisdiction and the Family Division
Under MCL 712A.2(a)(1), the family division of the circuit court has jurisdiction over juveniles who have allegedly committed offenses that would be crimes if committed by an adult. The age of jurisdiction in Michigan is under 18 at the time of the offense, with some specific exceptions discussed below.
Michigan’s “Raise the Age” reforms, effective in 2021, moved most 17-year-old offenders into the juvenile system — prior to that law, 17-year-olds were treated as adults. The law does not apply retroactively to closed cases, and it contains specific exceptions for cases transferred or waived to adult treatment.
Juvenile Case Process
A juvenile case in Michigan typically proceeds along a distinct procedural track:
- Petition: The prosecutor files a petition (not a complaint) alleging specific offenses and the basis for family court jurisdiction.
- Preliminary hearing and preliminary inquiry: The court determines whether there is reasonable cause to support the petition and whether the matter should proceed as a formal case, be diverted, or be handled informally under consent calendar.
- Consent calendar (MCR 3.932): For less serious matters, the court may proceed on the consent calendar — an informal track in which the juvenile agrees to specific conditions and, upon completion, the case is dismissed without adjudication.
- Adjudication: The formal hearing at which the court determines whether the allegations in the petition are proved beyond a reasonable doubt. In juvenile cases, adjudication replaces the adult concept of conviction.
- Disposition: After adjudication (or admission), the court holds a dispositional hearing to determine what orders and placements are appropriate.
Juveniles are entitled to counsel at every stage of the process. MCR 3.915 specifies the circumstances under which counsel must be appointed or retained.
Dispositions in the Family Division
Following adjudication, the family court has broad authority to enter dispositional orders under MCL 712A.18. The available dispositions range from informal to highly structured:
- Warning and dismissal.
- Probation with conditions — school attendance, counseling, community service, restitution, restrictions on activities, no-contact orders, and substance testing.
- Placement outside the home — with a relative, in foster care, in a private or public residential facility, or in a state juvenile justice facility.
- Commitment to the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services for placement.
- Orders requiring participation in specific treatment or educational programs.
- Restitution to victims.
- Combinations of the above, appropriate to the facts of the case and the juvenile’s situation.
The family court retains jurisdiction over most juvenile cases until the juvenile turns 21 — and in certain extended-jurisdiction cases, until age 23.
Designation and Waiver to Adult Court
Michigan provides two routes by which a juvenile case can be treated as an adult case: designation and waiver.
- Designated cases — MCL 712A.2d: A prosecutor may request that the family court designate the case as one in which the juvenile will be tried as an adult, under adult criminal procedure, in the family court. The court holds a hearing and decides based on specified statutory factors — seriousness of the alleged offense, prior record, treatment history, and public safety.
- Traditional waiver — MCL 712A.4: For juveniles 14 and older charged with certain serious felonies, the prosecutor may petition to waive the case out of the family division and into the adult criminal court. The court holds a waiver hearing and decides based on similar factors.
Automatic adult prosecution — MCL 600.606 and 764.1f: For a limited set of specified serious offenses, a juvenile 14 or older may be charged directly in adult criminal court without a waiver hearing. These “specified juvenile violations” include first- and second-degree murder, armed robbery, CSC-1, and certain other enumerated offenses.
Juvenile Lifers and the Miller Framework
The United States Supreme Court has held that mandatory life without parole for juvenile offenders violates the Eighth Amendment (Miller v. Alabama, 2012), and that ruling applies retroactively (Montgomery v. Louisiana, 2016). Michigan’s resentencing framework for juvenile lifers is codified at MCL 769.25 and MCL 769.25a. A sentence of life without parole on a juvenile offender requires an individualized Miller hearing at which the trial court weighs the statutory factors — the juvenile’s age and its hallmark features, family and home environment, participation in the offense, incompetencies associated with youth, and potential for rehabilitation — before any life-without-parole sentence can be imposed.
Juvenile Records, Expungement, and Set-Asides
Michigan’s Clean Slate framework, expanded by PA 187–200 of 2020, added significant new pathways to expunge juvenile adjudications. Under MCL 712A.18e, a juvenile may apply to set aside an adjudication as follows:
- Generally, one year after the final discharge of the matter, or after the applicant turns 18, whichever is later.
- Up to three adjudications may be set aside; certain serious offenses are excluded.
- The prosecutor and the victim, if any, receive notice of the application.
- If granted, the adjudication is not considered a conviction for any purpose — including licensing, employment, and firearm possession under state law.
Certain juvenile adjudications are also eligible for automatic set-aside under MCL 780.621g.
Common Defenses and Issues in Juvenile Cases
Juvenile cases have the same constitutional protections as adult cases, applied through the juvenile framework. Issues that frequently arise include:
- Sufficiency of proof: The prosecution must prove the allegations in the petition beyond a reasonable doubt at adjudication — the same burden as in adult court.
- Custodial interrogation and Miranda: Juveniles are entitled to Miranda warnings, and Michigan case law is particularly attentive to the voluntariness and comprehension of juvenile waivers.
- Parental presence: Michigan recognizes the significance of parental presence during police questioning of juveniles. The absence of a parent can affect the admissibility of statements.
- Competency: A juvenile may be found incompetent to proceed based on age-related factors as well as mental health considerations. Michigan has a specific juvenile competency framework under MCL 330.2060 et seq. as applied in juvenile cases.
- Suppression of evidence: Fourth Amendment challenges — to school searches, to vehicle searches, to warrantless home searches — apply in juvenile cases with particular attention to the New Jersey v. T.L.O. school-search framework.
- Diversion and consent-calendar eligibility: Early-stage decisions about whether a case is appropriate for the consent calendar, pre-petition diversion, or dismissal-based resolution can materially change outcomes.
- Mitigation and disposition advocacy: Dispositional decisions are guided by the juvenile’s individual circumstances. School records, treatment records, family circumstances, and individualized plans can change disposition outcomes significantly.
Collateral Consequences of a Juvenile Adjudication
While juvenile adjudications are not technically convictions, they carry meaningful consequences. Collateral consequences can include impacts on employment, housing, custody rights, citizenship, and standing in your community. Many school and college admissions applications ask about juvenile history. Licensing boards and certain employers consider juvenile records. Some juvenile adjudications count as prior convictions for specific enhancement purposes under later adult charges. Immigration consequences for non-citizen juveniles can be significant.
How the Firm Approaches Juvenile Cases
Juvenile cases deserve the same careful, substantive defense as adult matters — and then some. A juvenile adjudication is not a minor event, and juvenile court judges have broad authority that is best engaged by counsel who knows the system and the people in it.
We examine police reports, body cam videos, school records, forensic interview recordings, and digital evidence for what they actually contain rather than what the petition summarizes. We interview witnesses, gather physical and documentary evidence, and identify inconsistencies in the prosecution’s case whenever we can. We look for gaps in evidence, credibility problems with witnesses, and circumstances that support defenses.
We relentlessly and meticulously prepare our case files, research the law, and are at all times ready for court. We prepare every case from a litigation perspective first, as if it will go to trial or adjudication. This approach gives us leverage in negotiations and ensures we’re ready if the case reaches the courtroom.
Your defense should be as thorough and considered as the prosecution’s case against you. We don’t just accept the allegations as stated — we analyze them, investigate them, and contest them in court.
Speak With a Michigan Juvenile Defense Lawyer
For a confidential consultation about a juvenile petition, a designation or waiver hearing, a juvenile set-aside, or a post-conviction matter under MCL 769.25 in Washtenaw, Wayne, Jackson, Livingston, or Lenawee County, contact The Law Offices of Joseph A. Simon, PLLC at (734) 887-6200 or joe@simoncriminaldefense.com.
* AV-Preeminent is a peer-review rating from Martindale-Hubbell; it is not a certification of specialization.
** No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of Michigan. Awards and recognitions reflect past selections by third-party organizations and do not guarantee a similar outcome in any future matter.







