Michigan Probation Violation Charges
A probation violation in Michigan can result in the court revoking probation and imposing the original maximum sentence for the underlying conviction — including incarceration that may not have been part of the original sentence. Probation violations are taken seriously by Michigan courts, and a person accused of violating their probation conditions faces a proceeding where the standard of proof is lower than at a criminal trial and many of the procedural protections that apply at trial do not apply. The Law Offices of Joseph A. Simon, PLLC has over 40 years of experience defending clients facing probation violation proceedings throughout Washtenaw, Wayne, Jackson, Livingston, and Lenawee counties.
How Probation Works in Michigan
When a person is placed on probation under MCL 771.1 et seq., the court imposes a set of conditions that the person must follow for a specified period. Probation is an alternative to incarceration — but it is a conditional alternative. The person remains under the supervision of the court and a probation officer, and any alleged failure to comply with the conditions can result in a probation violation proceeding.
Common probation conditions include reporting regularly to a probation officer, maintaining employment or enrollment in school, submitting to drug and alcohol testing, completing community service hours, paying fines, costs, and restitution, attending counseling or treatment programs, not leaving the state without permission, not possessing firearms, and not committing any new criminal offenses.
The specific conditions vary depending on the underlying offense, the judge, and the circumstances of the case. Some conditions are standard in virtually every case; others are tailored to the specific offense or the defendant’s circumstances.
Types of Probation Violations
Probation violations in Michigan fall into two general categories:
Technical violations involve a failure to comply with a non-criminal condition of probation. Examples include missing a meeting with a probation officer, failing a drug test, failing to complete community service hours by the deadline, failing to pay fines or restitution, missing a counseling appointment, or leaving the state without permission. Technical violations do not involve new criminal conduct, but they are still taken seriously by the court.
New-offense violations occur when a person on probation is arrested for or charged with a new criminal offense. A new-offense violation is typically viewed more seriously than a technical violation because it suggests that the probationary period is not serving its rehabilitative purpose. The person does not need to be convicted of the new offense for the court to find a probation violation — the standard of proof at a probation violation hearing is lower than at a criminal trial.
The Probation Violation Process
A probation violation proceeding is initiated when the probation officer reports the alleged violation to the court or when the prosecuting attorney files a petition with the court. The court may issue a bench warrant for the defendant’s arrest or schedule the matter for a hearing.
The proceeding has two phases:
The violation hearing. At this hearing, the prosecution must prove by a preponderance of the evidence — meaning more likely than not — that the defendant violated a condition of probation. This is a significantly lower standard than the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard required at a criminal trial. The rules of evidence are relaxed at probation violation hearings, and hearsay evidence that would be inadmissible at trial may be considered by the court. The defendant has the right to be present, the right to counsel, and the right to present evidence and cross-examine witnesses.
The sentencing (or dispositional) hearing. If the court finds that a violation occurred, it proceeds to determine the appropriate consequence. The court has broad discretion at this stage and may continue probation under the same conditions, modify the conditions of probation (adding more restrictive conditions such as increased testing, counseling, or community service), extend the probationary period, or revoke probation and impose a jail or prison sentence up to the maximum for the original offense.
Consequences of a Probation Violation
The most significant consequence of a probation violation finding is that the court may revoke probation and impose incarceration. If a person was originally convicted of a felony carrying up to 10 years in prison and received probation instead of prison time, a probation violation can result in the court sentencing the person to prison for up to 10 years — the full statutory maximum for the original offense.
The court’s response depends on the nature and severity of the violation, the defendant’s compliance history, and the underlying offense. A first technical violation — such as a single missed appointment — is less likely to result in revocation than a pattern of noncompliance or a new criminal offense. However, the court retains discretion in every case, and even a single violation can lead to incarceration if the judge determines that probation is no longer appropriate.
Common Defenses and Strategies
Challenging the evidence of the violation. Although the standard of proof is lower than at trial, the prosecution must still prove that the violation occurred by a preponderance of the evidence. We examine the evidence supporting the alleged violation — probation officer reports, drug test results, records of missed appointments — and challenge its accuracy, reliability, and completeness.
Challenging drug test results. Positive drug tests are among the most common bases for probation violations. We evaluate the testing methodology, chain of custody, possibility of false positives, and whether the testing facility followed proper procedures. Certain medications, foods, and medical conditions can produce false positive results.
Substantial compliance. When a person has substantially complied with the conditions of probation and the violation is minor or isolated, we present evidence of the overall pattern of compliance. A single missed appointment in the context of months of full compliance is different from a pattern of disregard for probation conditions.
Circumstances beyond the defendant’s control. Some violations occur because of circumstances the defendant could not control — job loss affecting the ability to pay fines, transportation problems affecting the ability to attend meetings, medical emergencies, or family crises. We present evidence of the circumstances and argue that the violation was not willful.
Dispositional advocacy. Even when a violation is established, the most important phase of the proceeding is often the sentencing hearing. We present evidence of the defendant’s rehabilitation, employment, family responsibilities, and community ties, and argue for the least restrictive sanction consistent with public safety — continuation of probation with modified conditions rather than revocation.
Bond and Detention
When a probation violation is alleged, the court may issue a bench warrant for the defendant’s arrest. The defendant may be held in custody until the violation hearing, or the court may set bond. There is no automatic right to bond in a probation violation proceeding — the court considers the nature of the alleged violation, the defendant’s compliance history, and the risk of flight or danger to the community.
Securing release from custody while the violation proceeding is pending is often a critical first step. We advocate for reasonable bond conditions that allow the defendant to maintain employment and family obligations while the matter is resolved.
Probation Violation and the Underlying Sentence
It is important to understand the relationship between the probation violation proceeding and the original sentence. When the court revokes probation, it can impose any sentence that was available at the time of the original conviction, up to the statutory maximum. This means that a person who received no jail time as part of the original probation sentence can be sentenced to the maximum term of imprisonment upon revocation.
This is why effective defense at the probation violation stage is critical. The consequences of revocation can be more severe than the consequences of the original conviction, particularly for defendants who received probation as an alternative to incarceration.
How We Defend Probation Violation Cases
We prepare every case from a litigation perspective first, as if it will go to a contested hearing. In probation violation cases, this means thorough review of the probation conditions, the alleged violations, the evidence supporting the allegations, and the defendant’s compliance history. We also prepare thoroughly for the dispositional phase, gathering evidence of rehabilitation and presenting a plan for continued compliance. We relentlessly and meticulously prepare our case files, research the law, and are at all times ready for court.
Contact the Firm
For a confidential consultation about a probation violation, contact The Law Offices of Joseph A. Simon, PLLC at (734) 887-6200 or joe@simoncriminaldefense.com.










