Probation Violations in Dexter
An allegation of probation violation can expose a defendant to the full original sentence on the underlying offense. Probation violation hearings arising out of Dexter cases are heard in the court that imposed the original sentence — the 14A-3 District Court in downtown Chelsea for misdemeanor probations and the Washtenaw County Trial Court in Ann Arbor for felony probations. The procedural posture differs in important ways from the trial of the underlying offense.
Burden of Proof and Rules of Evidence
At a probation violation hearing, the prosecution must prove the alleged violation by a preponderance of the evidence — that it is more likely than not that the violation occurred. This is a lower standard than the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard that applies at trial. The Rules of Evidence applicable at trial are relaxed at violation hearings, and hearsay may be admissible if it bears sufficient indicia of reliability. The defendant retains the right to written notice of the alleged violation, the opportunity to be heard and to present evidence, the right to counsel, and the right to confront adverse witnesses subject to good-cause exceptions.
Sentencing Exposure
If the court finds a violation, it may continue probation, modify the terms of probation, or revoke probation and impose any sentence within the maximum penalty on the underlying offense. The sentencing exposure is not capped by the violation conduct itself; it is set by the maximum on the original charge. A technical violation in a felony case can therefore expose a defendant to a substantial prison sentence even where the violation conduct was relatively minor.
Common Allegations
Common probation-violation allegations include positive drug or alcohol screens, missed appointments with the probation officer, failure to complete required treatment or community service, failure to pay restitution or court-ordered fees, association with prohibited persons, and the commission of a new criminal offense. Each kind of allegation has its own evidentiary characteristics and its own dispositional considerations.
How Cases Are Handled in Dexter Courts
Probation in Dexter cases is supervised by the Washtenaw County probation department for cases sentenced in the 14A-3 District Court, and by the Michigan Department of Corrections for cases sentenced in the Washtenaw County Trial Court. Allegations of violation are typically filed by the supervising probation officer, with the prosecutor present at the hearing. The court may issue a bench warrant or a summons depending on the alleged violation and the defendant’s history.
Although, in Washtenaw County all preliminary examinations in Washtenaw County are centralized and held at the 14A-1 District Court.
Defending a Probation Violation
We approach probation violation hearings as their own substantive proceeding. We examine the precise conduct alleged, the conditions said to have been violated, the evidence supporting each allegation, and the absence of contrary explanation. Many violations resolve through admission and a negotiated disposition that addresses the underlying issue without revocation. Other violations are best contested. Whether to admit or contest depends on the strength of the evidence, the dispositional alternatives the court is likely to consider, and the client’s overall objectives. Where the alleged violation is a new criminal offense, we coordinate the defense across both proceedings to avoid statements or admissions in one that might prejudice the other.
Specialty Court Considerations
Cases supervised by a specialty docket — sobriety court, drug court, or veterans treatment court — operate under their own rules and dispositional alternatives. Violations in those programs may carry both intermediate sanctions within the program and the prospect of removal from the program with consequences set by the underlying sentence. We address specialty-court cases with attention to the specific procedural framework of the docket.
Related Practice Areas
For an experienced Dexter, MI probation violation defense lawyer, The Law Offices of Joseph A. Simon, PLLC has defended probation violation matters across criminal defense in Dexter for more than 40 years as part of our full criminal defense practice. For a deeper look at the statutes, penalties, and defenses that apply, see our pillar article on Michigan probation violation hearings. Related matters our firm handles in Dexter include Dexter OWI defense, Dexter domestic violence defense, and Dexter drug crime defense.
Contact the Firm
For a confidential consultation about a probation violation in Dexter, contact The Law Offices of Joseph A. Simon, PLLC at (734) 887-6200 or joe@simoncriminaldefense.com.





